Leadership vs Management: Why Organisations Need Both
We often hear people say “we don’t need managers, we need leaders.” It sounds compelling, but it misses the point. Organisations need both.
Without leadership, people lose sight of the bigger picture. Without management, nothing actually gets done.
Think of it like a garden. Leadership is deciding what to plant, where the sunlight will fall, and how the space should look when it’s in full bloom. Management is the daily work of watering, weeding, and pruning so the plants actually grow.
You can have the vision of a beautiful garden, but without the care it becomes overgrown. Equally, you can tend the soil perfectly, but without a clear plan it might never look like more than a patch of grass.
What a Great Leader Does Best
Leadership is about direction and inspiration. Leaders point towards a future state that others can believe in. They energise people, align them behind a common goal, and give confidence when the path ahead is uncertain. People who naturally fit leadership roles often have curiosity, courage, and the ability to simplify complexity into something motivating.
Different leadership styles bring this to life in different ways but all require core leadership skills such as vision and empathy.
But leadership isn’t enough on its own. A leader who only dreams big but can’t organise details risks losing the trust of their team.
Driving Order and Reliability
Management is about execution and consistency. Managers make sure systems run smoothly, deadlines are hit, and standards are upheld. They bring order, structure, and reliability to an organisation. The people who thrive here are often detail-focused, disciplined, and skilled at turning plans into repeatable processes.
Importantly, management is not just about systems. It’s also about people. Good managers support, coach, and hold their teams accountable. Where leaders tend to motivate direction, managers often ensure individuals have the clarity, resources, and feedback needed to perform day to day.
Yet management without leadership can become mechanical. Tasks get done, but people lose sight of why it matters.
Developing for Impact
Because leadership and management skills demand different muscles, the way people are developed should reflect that. Leaders benefit from building capabilities in visioning, storytelling, decision-making under uncertainty, and influencing diverse stakeholders.
Managers thrive when trained in planning, process design, resource allocation, and the practical side of people.
The most effective programmes, however, don’t isolate the two. They help individuals build range. Stretching leaders to think about execution, and stretching managers to think about purpose. Done well, this creates a pipeline of people who can shift altitude: zooming out to inspire and motivate zooming back in to deliver on specific goals.
Harmony
The highest-performing organisations don’t choose leadership over management, or vice versa. They blend the two. They identify leaders who can set direction and pay attention to detail. They identify managers who can execute the plan and remind their teams of the bigger picture.
Just like the garden, you need someone to imagine what could be, and someone to ensure it flourishes day to day. When leadership and management are both present – and respected as distinct but complementary – the result is growth that lasts.
About the author
